But Margaret wasn’t finished.
“Do you know why you all attended the same school?”
We stared at her.
“It wasn’t entirely a coincidence.”
Years earlier, Margaret and several relatives had agreed to live near one another so Mary’s daughters could grow up together, even if they didn’t know they were sisters.
They intended to explain everything when the girls were older.
But every year, they postponed the conversation.
“And when exactly were you going to tell us?” I cried. “When we were eighty?”
Margaret lowered her head.
“We were wrong. The longer we waited, the more frightened we became of admitting how long we’d kept the truth from you.”
Linda stood up.
“So every time we called each other sisters, you knew it was true?”
Margaret nodded through her tears.
“I’m sorry for every year you lost.”
That night, the four of us stayed together, sharing childhood memories that suddenly meant something entirely different.