PART 3: The Witness Who Had Been Paid to Lie
Rebecca refused to surrender the original recording directly to the same office whose former prosecutor appeared in it.
Instead, she arranged for the evidence to be preserved and submitted through the appropriate legal channels.
By early afternoon, the emergency application was filed.
I waited inside a holding room while the clock moved toward six.
Every minute felt unbearable.
I knew that a shocking recording was not the same as a legal finding of innocence.
Advertisement
The video showed misconduct and threatening behavior.
But it did not show Arthur's murder.
The state could still argue that I had killed him for reasons unrelated to the corruption.
Rebecca understood that danger.
So she began searching for evidence connecting the threats to the night Arthur died.
The first breakthrough came from something Arthur had said in the recording.
"Copies can disappear."
Rebecca remembered that several items had been listed in police inventory but never provided to my original defense team.
Advertisement
Among them was a notebook containing Arthur's appointment records.
The prosecution had described it as irrelevant.
Now Rebecca suspected those pages might reveal whom Arthur had been meeting before his death.
She requested immediate access to the complete inventory and related records.
Meanwhile, an investigator working with her contacted Ruth Garner.
Ruth was the neighbor whose testimony had helped convict me.
For five years, I had hated hearing her name.
She had looked straight at the jury and claimed she saw me leaving Arthur's house near the time of the murder.
Advertisement
Her words helped turn my desperate attempt to save him into evidence of guilt.
But when the investigator showed Ruth a still image from Arthur's recording, her confidence disappeared.
She recognized Detective Price.
She recognized Kenneth Hale.
And she began crying.
At first, Ruth refused to speak.
Then she admitted that Detective Price had visited her before my trial.
He told her that Arthur's killer needed to be identified quickly.
He suggested that if she cooperated, certain outstanding financial problems involving her property could be resolved.
Advertisement
Ruth insisted she had genuinely seen a woman near Arthur's house.
But she admitted she hadn't seen a gun.
She hadn't seen the woman's face clearly.
And she hadn't been certain about the time.
Price had supplied those details during repeated interviews.
By the time she testified, she was repeating the version he had encouraged her to believe.
The investigator asked whether she would sign a sworn statement.
Ruth hesitated.
Then she looked at the photograph of me that Rebecca had sent.
Advertisement
For the first time, she appeared to understand what her testimony had helped accomplish.
"Is she really going to die tonight?"
The investigator nodded.
Ruth covered her mouth.
"Then I need to tell the truth."
Her signed declaration reached Rebecca shortly after three o'clock.
The witness who had helped convict me was now admitting that critical parts of her testimony had been shaped by the detective investigating the murder.
Rebecca immediately added the declaration to the emergency filing.
But the clock kept moving.
Advertisement
At four o'clock, Mitchell visited me.
He explained that the legal process was still underway.
I looked toward the small clock above the door.
"Do you think they'll stop it?"
He didn't offer false reassurance.
"I know your attorney is doing everything she can."
I lowered my head.
"Chloe brought the truth here."
Mitchell nodded.
"She brought something very important."
I thought about my daughter standing in the visitation room, clutching her canvas bag.
I thought about the music box Arthur had given her.
For years, she had listened to that melody without knowing a hidden compartment contained evidence that might save her mother's life.
I wondered whether Arthur had expected me to discover it.
Perhaps he had planned to tell me about it before he died.
Perhaps he had hidden it because he feared his office would be searched.
Whatever his intentions, he had protected a copy of the truth from the people threatening him.
At approximately four-thirty, Rebecca called.
Her voice sounded strained.
Advertisement
"We found something else."
I gripped the telephone.
"What?"
"The original emergency-call recording."
I held my breath.
She explained that the dispatch audio from the night of Arthur's murder contained information not reflected in the prosecution's trial presentation.
I remembered calling emergency services while pressing my hands against Arthur's wound.
I remembered crying so hard that the dispatcher repeatedly asked me to slow down.
But Rebecca wasn't referring only to my call.
Another person had contacted emergency services minutes earlier.
May you like
Chapter 5: My husband brought his pregnant mistress to the luxury wedding where we were supposed to renew our vows. i068
Chapter 4: My husband brought his pregnant mistress to the luxury wedding where we were supposed to renew our vows. u068
Chapter 3: My husband brought his pregnant mistress to the luxury wedding where we were supposed to renew our vows. t068
The caller reported hearing a gunshot and seeing a dark vehicle speeding away from Arthur's property.
The recording included part of a license plate.
That information had never been presented to my jury.
Rebecca told me investigators were now comparing the description with vehicles associated with Detective Price.
I began crying.
For five years, the prosecution had insisted no evidence placed anyone else near Arthur's house.
Now there was a witness they had never disclosed.
A vehicle they had never explained.
Advertisement
And a recording they had never allowed my defense to hear.
"Rebecca, is that enough?"
She hesitated.
"It should at least require serious judicial review."
I pressed my forehead against the wall.
"Please don't let them kill me."
Her voice broke.
"I'm fighting, Elena."
At five o'clock, the lower court issued its decision.
Rebecca called again.
I knew something was wrong before she spoke.
The silence lasted too long.
Then she told me that the application for a stay had been denied.
Advertisement
My knees weakened.
"What?"
"The judge says the new evidence raises serious questions but hasn't been sufficiently authenticated to justify the relief requested at this stage."
I covered my mouth.
Rebecca continued.
"We're filing an emergency request with the higher court right now."
I looked at the clock.
Only one hour remained.
Then she said something that made my blood run cold.
"Elena, the state has just confirmed that it intends to proceed unless a higher court intervenes."
