We walked back across the pasture together. My arm around her shoulders. Her face pressed against my shoulder so she couldn’t look back. She didn’t make a sound the whole way.
Then we got to the porch steps. And she sat down on the bottom one. And she looked at her rubber boots. The same ones she wore every morning to feed him.
And she broke.
I sat down next to her on the step. I held her while she cried. Big, gasping sobs. The kind that shake your whole body.
Behind us, in the kitchen, the radio was still playing. The pancake batter was still sitting in the bowl on the counter.
Out in the pasture, Arnold was working. I could hear the hoist.
“Who did it?” Kinley finally asked. Into my shoulder. “Mom. Who shot him?”
I didn’t want to tell her.
But I’ve never lied to my daughter. Not once. Not about Santa Claus, not about where babies come from, not about where hamburger comes from.