“Lauren,” I said quietly. “Why did you laugh while my car went into the water?”
She didn’t answer. She opened her mouth and nothing came out.
“You laughed,” I said. “I heard you. Before I even turned around, I heard you laughing. And you were still laughing when Ryan came up the lawn. You were wiping your eyes.”
She stared past my shoulder, up the lawn. I turned my head and followed her eyes. She was looking at her husband. Ryan was standing at the top of the lawn with his arms crossed, watching us. His face was very still.
I turned back to my daughter. She was trembling.
“I thought it would be funny,” she whispered. “Ryan said it would be funny.”
Chapter Five: Emma’s Video
But Lauren’s cousin Emma had kept hers.
Emma is my late sister’s daughter, twenty-eight, a nurse in the cardiac unit at Northside Hospital in Atlanta. She’s quiet and kind, and she’d been sitting at the end of a picnic table all evening, not laughing much at Ryan’s jokes. When Ryan ordered everybody to delete their videos, she didn’t. She walked down the lawn to the dock with her phone in her hand and her face set like stone.