Because my mother had clearly suffered. In silence. Like all of us.
I took a slow breath.
Mom, I said quietly, you’ve been carrying this for eight years too?
She nodded. Sobbing.
I reached across the table. I took her hands.
I said, Mom. Listen to me. The same thing Jeremy said to David. It wasn’t your fault.
She said, But if I’d gone.
I said, You can’t know that. Maybe you’d have been watching Jeremy. And Janice still slips. You can’t rewrite it with a thousand what-ifs.
I said, A five-year-old slipped on a wet rock. Near water. In a single unguarded second. That can happen to the most careful parent. The most watchful grandmother. In an instant.
My mother wept.
I said, We’ve all been doing it. All of us. Me. David. Jeremy. And now I find out, you too.
I said, Four people. Carrying the weight of one terrible accident. Each of us convinced we’re the one who failed her.