I set the coffee down.Order Coffee Beans
“Ethan,” I said slowly. “What did you do?”
“Nothing she didn’t ask for,” he said.
“What does that mean? What did you send her? Ethan, if you sent her something mean, if you sent her, like, a calendar with a big circle around year five, I swear to God—”
“It’s not mean.”
“Then what is it?”
Before he could answer, my phone lit up on the nightstand.
MOM.
I stared at it. My mother never called on Saturday mornings. Saturday mornings were for open houses. She’d be at a property by nine, setting out cookies and fresh flowers.
It was eight-forty.
I picked up.
“Mom?”
For a second, there was no sound. Just breathing. Fast, shallow breathing.
Then my mother’s voice. But not her voice. Not the polished, confident real estate voice I’d heard my whole life. This voice was thin and shaking. Like a little girl’s.
“Olivia,” she said. “I just opened it.”
“Opened what? Mom, are you okay?”
“Why would he send me this?” She was crying. My mother was crying. I hadn’t heard my mother cry since my father’s funeral. Twenty-five years. “Olivia, why would he send me this? Where did he… how did he…”
I looked at Ethan.
He reached over and took my hand. Still smiling. But his eyes were wet now.
“Put her on speaker,” he said.
I put her on speaker.
I set the phone on the bed between us.
“Mom,” I said. “Ethan’s here. You’re on speaker.”
My mother didn’t say anything. I could hear her breathing. Ragged. Shaky.
“Linda,” Ethan said gently. “Good morning.”
“Where did you get this?” My mother’s voice cracked right down the middle. “Where did you get this, Ethan?”
“What did he send you?” I said. “Somebody tell me what’s going on.”
There was a long silence.
Then my mother said, very quietly:Track Pregnancy
“Keys.”
“Keys?”
“Two keys. On a ring. With a little silver horseshoe.” Her voice broke completely. “It’s your father’s key ring, Olivia. It’s Mike’s. I gave it to him on our first anniversary. I bought it at the county fair for four dollars. I’d know it anywhere.”
I couldn’t breathe.
“And a picture,” my mother whispered. “There’s a picture.”
“Of what?”
She made a sound. Like something tearing.
Discover more
Get Parenting Tips
Wedding
Plan Family Trips
“His car,” she said. “Mike’s car.”
I turned to Ethan.
“What car?”
Ethan took a breath.
“The blue one,” he said softly. “The one you used to sit on the hood of. When you were little. The one you told me about on our second date.”
I stared at him.
I had told him. I’d forgotten that I’d told him. We were sitting in a booth at a diner on Route 9 at one in the morning, eating pancakes. And I’d told him about my father. The only real memory I had of him. Sitting on the hood of a big, dark blue car in the sun, with the engine rumbling under me like a sleeping lion, and my father standing next to me singing the wrong words to a Bob Seger song.
“A 1969 Chevelle SS,” Ethan said. “Fathom Blue. Black interior. Three ninety-six big block. Your dad bought it in 1992 for twelve hundred dollars. It didn’t run. He rebuilt it himself. Took him three years.”
“How do you know that?” my mother whispered through the phone.
“Because I found it,” Ethan said.
The silence on the other end of the phone went on for so long I thought the call had dropped.
“That’s impossible,” my mother finally said. “I sold that car in 2001. To a man from Kentucky. I needed the money for the funeral. I never knew his name. I never saw it again.”
“His name was Harold Pruitt,” Ethan said. “He paid you thirty-two hundred dollars for it. He drove it back to Paducah, and he parked it in his barn, and he meant to fix it up, and he never did. And then he died in 2014, and it sat in that barn for another eight years with a tarp over it and raccoons living in the back seat.”
“How,” my mother said. “How do you know any of this?”
Ethan squeezed my hand.
“Because I’ve been looking for it,” he said, “since the night of our wedding.”Book Venues
I need to tell you about the night of our wedding.
Not the toast. Something else. Something I didn’t know about until that moment, sitting on my bed with my phone on speaker and my coffee going cold.
Ethan told it.
“After the toast,” he said. “After you went into the bathroom, Liv. Your mom went outside. To the parking lot. I saw her go. And I followed her.”
“You never told me that,” I said.
“No,” he said. “I didn’t.”
“I was smoking,” my mother said quietly through the phone. “I quit in 1997. I bought a pack from the bartender. I hadn’t smoked in twenty-three years.”
“She was standing next to her car,” Ethan said. “That white Lexus. Crying. And I walked up to her, and I said, ‘Linda, can we talk?’ And she said…”
He stopped. He looked at the phone.
“Tell her what I said,” my mother whispered. “It’s all right. Tell her.”
Discover more
families
Coffee
Get Marriage Tips
Ethan took a breath.
“She said, ‘Mike was a mechanic too. Did she tell you that?’ And I said yes. And she said, ‘He was good. So good. Everybody loved him. And he worked himself to death under somebody else’s truck and left me with a seven-year-old and eleven thousand dollars of debt and a car I couldn’t afford to keep.’”
My mother made a small, broken sound.
“And she said, ‘Every time I look at you, I see him. Your hands. Your smile. The way you talk about engines. And I know how it ends. I know exactly how it ends. And I can’t watch my daughter go through what I went through.’”
I put my hand over my mouth.
“And then,” Ethan said, “she laughed. This awful laugh. And she said, ‘You want to prove me wrong? You want me to believe you’re different? Bring back Mike’s Chevelle. Bring it back running. Then I’ll believe a mechanic can do something besides break a woman’s heart.’”
He looked down at our hands.
“And then she threw her cigarette on the ground and went back inside,” he said. “And I stood there in that parking lot for a long time.”
“I was drunk,” my mother whispered. “I didn’t mean it. It was an impossible thing to ask. I said it because it was impossible. Because I knew nobody could ever do it.”
“I know,” Ethan said. “But I told you I’d remember.”
“I’ll remember that.”
That’s what he’d said at the reception. Raising his glass. Smiling at her.
I’d thought he meant the insult. I’d thought it was a quiet little threat. A promise to prove her wrong someday.
I didn’t know he was talking about the car.Compare Cars
“Five years,” I said. I was crying now. “You’ve been looking for my dad’s car for five years?”
“Three and a half, actually,” Ethan said. “It took me a year and a half to find it.”
“How?”
“You had a box,” he said. “In the closet at the old apartment. A shoebox. With your dad’s stuff in it. His watch. His Zippo. Some photographs.” He smiled a little. “And a registration card. From 1999. With the VIN number on it.”
I remembered the box. My mother gave it to me when I graduated high school. I’d looked through it once and put it away. I couldn’t bear to look at it.
“I ran the VIN,” Ethan said. “Every database I could find. Title records. Insurance records. DMV records in six states. Most of it was a dead end. Harold Pruitt never re-registered it. It just disappeared after 2001. Like it fell off the earth.”
“So how did you find it?” my mother asked. Her voice was steadier now. Just a little.
“Facebook,” Ethan said.
I actually laughed. Through the tears. “Facebook?”
“There’s a group,” Ethan said, a little embarrassed. “For Chevelle collectors. Forty thousand members. I posted the VIN and a picture from your shoebox. Your dad standing next to the car in 1995 with his arm around you, Linda. You’re wearing a yellow sundress.”
My mother made a sound on the phone.
“I remember that dress,” she whispered.
“Eighteen months,” Ethan said. “Nothing. Then one night, a guy named Bobby Pruitt messaged me. Harold’s grandson. He’d seen the post. He said his grandpa had a blue Chevelle in his barn in Paducah. Had been there since before Bobby was born. Nobody ever touched it. Grandpa always said he’d get to it someday.”
“And you bought it,” I said.
“I drove down to Paducah in March of year two. Remember? I said I was going to a parts auction.”
I remembered. He’d been gone two days. He came home with sunburn on his neck and a strange look on his face.
“I walked into that barn,” Ethan said. “And Bobby pulled the tarp off. And it was there. Rusted through in the floor pans. Raccoon nest in the back seat. Four flat tires. The engine seized. Mouse droppings in the glove box.” He laughed softly. “And it was the most beautiful thing I’d ever seen. Because I knew it was his. I knew it was the car you sat on, Liv. I could see it. I could see you sitting on that hood.”
“How much did you pay for it?” I whispered.
He didn’t answer right away.
“The coffee can,” he said finally.
I closed my eyes.
The coffee can. The Folgers can in the closet. Every Friday. Twenty dollars, fifty dollars. What’s the can for? The future.Order Coffee Beans
“You told me that was for the shop,” I said.
“Half of it was,” Ethan said. “The other half was for this.”
“I restored it at the shop,” Ethan said. “After hours. Every night after the guys went home. Weekends. Three years. Mostly by myself. Rafael helped sometimes. And Teddy, when I needed somebody to hold a light.”
“The blue car,” I said slowly. “In bay three. Under the cover. You told me it was a customer’s car. A restoration job for some guy in Chesterfield.”
“I lied,” Ethan said. “I’m sorry. It’s the only time I’ve ever lied to you. I wanted it to be a surprise. I didn’t know if I could finish it. I didn’t want to promise you something I couldn’t deliver.”
My mother was crying again on the phone. Quietly this time.
“It runs?” she whispered. “Ethan. Does it run?”
“It runs, Linda,” Ethan said. “It runs like the day Mike finished it.”
I was sobbing now. Openly. Sitting on my bed in my pajamas with my coffee cold and my phone on speaker.
“Where is it?” I said. “Where’s the car?”
Ethan smiled.
“It’s in your mom’s driveway,” he said. “Teddy and Rafael drove it over at six this morning. They parked it, put the keys in the mailbox, and left the package on the porch. That’s why she called.”
“It’s in my driveway?” my mother said.
I heard her move. I heard a door open. I heard her breathing change.
And then, through the phone, I heard my mother scream.
Not a scared scream. Not an angry one.
A scream like she’d been holding it in for twenty-five years.
“We’re coming over,” Ethan said into the phone. “Linda? We’ll be there in twenty minutes. Is that okay?”
She couldn’t answer. I could hear her crying. Gasping.
“Mom,” I said. “Mom, we’re coming. Okay? We’re coming right now.”
“Okay,” she whispered. “Okay.”
I hung up. I looked at Ethan.
He was sitting on the edge of the bed with tears running down his face. He was trying to smile. He couldn’t quite manage it.
“I didn’t know if it was the right thing,” he said. “I’ve been terrified for three years. That it would hurt her. That it would make things worse. That she’d hate me even more.”
I threw my arms around his neck.
I couldn’t say anything. I just held him. I held him so tight I could feel his heart pounding against my chest.
“You crazy man,” I finally whispered into his shoulder. “You crazy, stubborn, wonderful man.”
“Is that a good thing?”
“It’s the best thing.”
We drove over in Ethan’s truck. I didn’t even change out of my pajamas. I just pulled on a hoodie and sneakers and got in the truck.
My mother lives in a big brick colonial in Wildwood Estates. Two-car garage. Perfectly trimmed boxwoods along the front walk. A flagpole with an American flag.Track Pregnancy
We turned onto her street.
And there it was.
Parked in her circular driveway, in front of her white Lexus, gleaming in the October sun.
A 1969 Chevelle SS. Fathom Blue.
So dark it was almost black in the shade. But where the sun hit it, it turned the deep, rich blue of the ocean at night. The chrome bumpers shone like mirrors. The black vinyl top was perfect. The tires were new. The white stripes on the hood were crisp and clean.
It looked like it had just rolled off a showroom floor. It looked like 1969.
It looked exactly like I remembered.
And sitting on the curb next to it, in her bathrobe, was my mother.
I’d never seen my mother in a bathrobe outside the house. Not once. Not in thirty-two years. She doesn’t go to the mailbox without lipstick.
She was sitting on the curb with her knees pulled up to her chest, wearing a pink terrycloth robe and fuzzy slippers. Her hair was a mess. No makeup. Her face was swollen and red.
She was holding the key ring in both hands. A silver horseshoe. Two old keys.
When Ethan’s truck pulled up, she looked up.
I got out before the truck even stopped all the way. I ran to her. I didn’t think. I just ran.
She stood up. And I threw my arms around my mother. And she held onto me. Hard. Harder than she’d held me since I was little.
“Olivia,” she kept saying. “Olivia. Olivia.”
“I know, Mom. I know.”
“It’s his car. It’s his car. It’s really his car.”
“I know.”
She pulled back. She held my face in both hands. The way she used to when I was a little girl with a scraped knee.
“I sold it,” she whispered. “I sold your father’s car to a stranger for thirty-two hundred dollars. I sold it for the funeral. I sold it because I couldn’t stand to look at it. I couldn’t stand to have it in the garage. Every time I opened the door, I’d see it, and I’d see him under it.” She was crying so hard she could barely talk. “I never told you. I never told you I sold it. You came home from school and asked where Daddy’s blue car went, and I told you it went to car heaven. You were seven. You believed me.”
“I remember,” I said. I did. I’d forgotten until that moment, but I remembered. Car heaven. “I used to think it was up there with him.”
My mother laughed. A horrible, wet, beautiful laugh.
“And now it’s back,” she said. “It came back.”
Ethan was standing by the truck. He hadn’t come closer. He was standing there with his hands in his pockets, watching us, the way he’d stood in the hallway outside the bathroom at our wedding. Waiting.Book Venues
My mother looked up and saw him.
She let go of me. She walked across the driveway toward him. Slowly. In her pink bathrobe and fuzzy slippers.
She stopped right in front of him.
For a long moment, they just looked at each other.
My mother is five foot four. Ethan is six foot one. She had to tilt her head all the way back.
“There’s something in the glove box,” Ethan said quietly. “I didn’t put it in the package. I thought… I thought you should find it yourself.”
My mother stared at him.
“What is it?”
“Something I found,” Ethan said. “When I took the dash apart. In the second year. It was wedged up behind the glove box. Between the box and the firewall. Like it slipped down back there and got stuck.” He swallowed. “I didn’t read it, Linda. I swear. I saw the name on the envelope, and I put it right back. It’s not mine to read.”
My mother turned and looked at the car.
Then she walked over to it. She opened the passenger door. The hinges didn’t squeak. Ethan had oiled them.
She climbed in. She sat in the passenger seat. Black vinyl, brand new, but the same pattern. The same seat she’d sat in a thousand times in 1995.
She reached out with a shaking hand and opened the glove box.
Inside, there was an envelope.
Old. Yellowed. Soft at the edges. The flap was still sealed.
See more on the next page