The first year was the hardest. Not because the grief was loudest then — it wasn’t, not always — but because everything still had his shape. The indent in the couch cushion where he sat. The mug he used every morning, the one with the chipped handle that I kept washing and putting back because throwing it away felt like a decision I wasn’t ready to make. Lily’s bedtime, which had always been his, became mine, and I had to learn how to do the voices for her stories and which pages to linger on and when she wanted me to read faster because she was tired and when she wanted me to read slower because she wasn’t.
By the second year I was better at it. That was the worst discovery: how efficiently you could rebuild around an absence when you had no other option. I stopped setting two coffee mugs out in the morning. I stopped checking my phone the way I used to, hoping for his name on the screen. I learned the shape of a life that was smaller and quieter and mine in a way it had never quite been before, and sometimes — not often, but sometimes — that felt close to something I could bear.
Lily started third grade that fall. She made two good friends, girls named Priya and Cassidy. She joined the dance program at Clover Hill because Owen used to call her his little dancer and she said she wanted to get good enough that he would see her someday. I signed the permission slip and kept my face completely still.
I picked up an extra project at work. I called my mother more. I learned how to fix the leaky faucet in the guest bathroom because Owen was not there to call and there was nobody else.
Ferndale is a small enough city that people noticed Owen was gone. I got the questions at the grocery store, at Lily’s school pickup, from colleagues who had met him at the holiday party two years before. I said we were separated. I kept my voice neutral. I kept moving.
Two years passed the way years do when you are surviving them: one Tuesday at a time.
CHAPTER TWO: THE FLYER
Lily brought home the flyer on a Wednesday.
It was pink — bright, almost fluorescent pink, which should have felt like a coincidence but didn’t. There was a cartoon of a dancing father and daughter, and block letters across the top: CLOVER HILL ANNUAL SPRING PERFORMANCE: FATHER-DAUGHTER BALLET SHOWCASE. ALL FAMILIES WELCOME.
She set it on the kitchen counter while I was making dinner and didn’t say anything.
I looked at it for a moment.
She watched me read it.
“You could have Uncle Pete take you,” I said, keeping my voice light. My brother Pete had been to every one of Lily’s school events that required a second adult. He was not a perfect substitute, but he was reliable and he loved her and he wore whatever costumes Lily decided he needed to wear.
“Uncle Pete’s not my dad,” she said.
She said it simply, without anger, the way a child states something that is factually true.
I turned back to the stove.
“I know.”
That night, after she went to bed, I sat at the kitchen table and I called Owen’s number for the first time in almost a year.
It rang four times.
Voicemail.
I called again.
Voicemail.
I called eleven more times over the next two days. I left three messages. I sent two texts. I tried the email address I had for him, knowing he hadn’t checked it in months. I called the number of the friend he had said he was staying with, the only name he had given me — no answer.
NEXT PAGE TO CONTINUE READING