He took his hands down. His eyes were red.
"He came to see me," he said. "In prison. At the state facility in Camp Hill. The first time was in March of 2014. I'd been there four months. I'd pleaded guilty. And a guard said you've got a visitor, and I thought it was my lawyer." He laughed, wetly. "And I walked into the visiting room, and there was an old man at the table with his hat in his hands. And I knew him. And I thought: this is it. He's here to kill me."
"He wasn't."
"No." Randall shook his head slowly. "He sat down. He looked at me for a very long time. And he said, I'm Walter Garrity. I poured you your last beer. I want you to know that I know that."
I put my hand over my mouth.
"And I started to cry, and I couldn't stop. And he sat there. And when I was done, he said, Randy, I didn't come to forgive you. That's not mine to do. I came because we're the only two men on this earth who know exactly what happened that night, and I thought we ought to be in the same room."