My First Love Vanished Until His Lookalike Found Me

I learned about his ex-wife, Karen, who’d left in 2009 but who he still talked to every couple of weeks. About his daughter, Nora, who was twenty-four and lived in Denver and worked at an animal shelter. About his job. He sold insurance, just like his father had, after the garage.

“Dad sold insurance?” I said. “Benjamin? Benjamin Hale sold insurance?”

“For thirty years. Why?”

“He couldn’t do long division,” I said.

Edward laughed so hard the waitress came over to check on us.

I learned that he couldn’t cook a single thing, but he made an excellent pie crust. His mother had taught him. Dorothy’s pie crust.

“Will you make me one sometime?” I asked.

“Cherry or apple?”

“What did he like?”

“Cherry,” Edward said.

“Then cherry,” I said.

He brought it the next Tuesday. In a foil pan, still warm.

We ate it with Benjamin, in his room, with plastic forks. Benjamin ate two pieces and got cherry juice on his cardigan.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *