My daughter asked me not to come for Christmas.

The scarf.

The flash drive.

Her father breaking the bedroom door.

Richard watched her with the wounded expression he had used throughout her childhood whenever she disappointed him.

Lauren looked directly at him.

“You taught me that family meant protecting one another,” she said. “But you only protected people when they obeyed you.”

Matthew testified next.

Celeste testified under a cooperation agreement and received probation for unlawful entry, evidence concealment, and conspiracy-related conduct.

Her marriage to Richard was annulled.

Charles resigned from the defense committee.

I took the stand last.

Richard’s attorney asked whether bitterness from the divorce influenced my testimony.

“No.”

“Did you resent your former husband?”

“Sometimes.”

“Did you wish to see him punished?”

“I wished to see him stopped.”

The attorney displayed family photographs.

Christmases.

Birthdays.

Our wedding.

“Was this man always a criminal?”

“No.”

“When did he become one?”

“I do not know.”

“Then how can you claim to understand his intent?”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *