“Thank you,” I heard Greg say into his shoulder. “Thank you for not listening to me.”
“Somebody had to,” Elliot said.
Sophie took one look at her uncle and burst out laughing.
“Oh my God,” she said. “There’s two of you. There’s actually two of you.”
That Thanksgiving was the loudest one we’d had in years. Lynn came with her husband and her kids. Patty came over for pie. Elliot told embarrassing stories about Raymond Cole’s terrible singing voice, and Greg laughed so hard he cried, and I realized it was the first time he’d ever heard a single funny story about his own father.
That night, after everyone had gone to bed, I found Greg and Elliot sitting together on the back porch in the cold, looking at old photographs Elliot had brought. Raymond Cole as a young man in the Navy. Raymond Cole fishing on a lake in Ohio. Raymond Cole holding a baby that might have been Elliot. And one very old photograph, black and white and torn at the corner, of a tall young man holding a little boy in a pair of overalls on his knee.