It’s slow work. You can’t rush it. If you dump too much loose fill at once, it settles unevenly and the water finds the soft spots. So I pushed and packed and pushed and packed, lift after lift, and the gully slowly filled from the bottom up.
Then, as it came up near the top, I did what Ted Rutledge did in 1961. I didn’t bring it back up to the level of the field. I shaped it wide and shallow, a broad swale about sixty feet across and maybe a foot and a half deep in the middle, with gentle sloping sides you could drive a hay rake across without noticing. A grass waterway. When the water came off the hill next time, it would spread out and slow down and run across grass instead of cutting into bare dirt.
Grass would hold it this time. That was the whole idea. You can’t stop water from running downhill. You can only give it a place to run that it can’t tear up.